Notify me of new HIR pieces! |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
What is wrong with the media? Why can't it report the Israeli-Lebanese conflict
fairly? Historical and Investigative Research - 8 August
2006 1 | 2
Two days ago Honest Reporting brought to my
attention the scandal of the Reuters photographer who doctored (at
least) one of his photos in order to attack Israel. Here is the
photograph: That this photo was doctored was shown by Charles
Johnson, who runs a blog called Little Green Footballs. About this
photo, Johnson explained: “This Reuters
photograph shows blatant evidence of manipulation. Notice the repeating
patterns in the smoke; this is almost certainly caused by using the Photoshop
‘clone’ tool to add more smoke to the image. Smoke simply
does not contain repeating symmetrical patterns like this, and you can see
the repetition in both plumes of smoke. There’s really no question about it.
It’s not only the plumes of smoke that were ‘enhanced.’ There are also cloned
buildings.”[1] The point of doctoring the photograph was to impress
the viewer with a picture of great ‘devastation’ wrought by the Israelis. Honest
Reporting explains that, “Faced with an
onslaught of bloggers taking up the case and demonstrating how clearly the
picture had been doctored, Reuters finally came clean and admitted
that the picture was a lie.”[2] To control the damage, Reuters issued what is
called a ‘picture kill’ telling everybody not to use it.
|
|
Is this article useful? Help us do
more with a donation . |
|
Clearly, something is very wrong with the mass
media, whether or not you accept the specific model defended by HIR.
As I said in
a previous piece on the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah, the
media cannot be trusted to report this conflict fairly, and we should expect
many more fraudulent accusations against the Israelis. Over and over again,
the Western ruling classes, with their stranglehold on the world media, will
tell you that the Jews are monsters, like they have for 2000 years. Don’t believe it.
|
Take me to the |
in this series. |
Israel at War
-- An HIR Series |
|
█
What is Hezbollah? █
What caused this war? █ Understanding the
US position | 1 █ Understanding the
US position | 2 |
█ Who is killing Lebanese
civilians? | 1 █ Who is killing Lebanese
civilians? | 2 █ What is wrong with the
media? | 1 █ What is wrong with the
media? | 2 |
_____________________________________________________
Footnotes and Further Reading
_____________________________________________________
[1] Honest
Reporting’s piece is here:
“Bold Distortions and Outright Lies: A Reuters photo turns out to be an
outright lie, manipulated to make damage in Beirut appear much worse than
reality”; Honest Reporting; 6 August 2006.
http://honestreporting.com/articles/45884734/
critiques/Bold_Distortions_and_Outright_Lies.asp
Charles Johnson’s piece is here:
http://littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/?
entry=21956_Reuters_Doctoring_Photos_from_Beirut&only
[2] “Bold
Distortions and Outright Lies: A Reuters photo turns out to be an outright
lie, manipulated to make damage in Beirut appear much worse than reality”;
Honest Reporting; 6 August 2006.
http://honestreporting.com/articles/45884734/c
ritiques/Bold_Distortions_and_Outright_Lies.asp
[3] Reuters |
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reuters
[4] MAD MEL
COULDN'T HAVE PICKED A WORSE TIME, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
(Pennsylvania), August 7, 2006 Monday, SOONER EDITION, LIFESTYLE; Pg. A-2,
240 words, Ruth Ann Dailey
[5] When he came
back from his tour of Lebanon, Jan Egeland, U.N. Under-Secretary-General for
Humanitarian Affairs, said that “I heard them [Hezbollah] saying they were
proud of losing fewer armed men than civilians. It’s hard to see how they
could be proud of such a situation.”
SOURCE:
REVEALED How Hezbollah puts the innocent at risk; They don't care, Sunday
Mail (South Australia), July 30, 2006 Sunday, Final Edition, NEWS; Pg. 4, 599
words, Chris Tinkler
[6] “Reuters
admits altering Beirut photo”; Y-net; 6 August 2006; by Yaakov Lappin
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3286966,00.html#n
[7] “The American
public understands what the war between Israel and Hezbollah is about and
what it is not about. It is not about occupation; it is not about an effort
by poor, oppressed Palestinians to get Israel out of their land; it is not
about a two-state solution.
What it is about is the fate of the democratic State
of Israel, which was attacked, once again, by enemies dedicated to its
destruction. That Americans see the reality clearly is manifest in a pair of
polls: No fewer than 83% say Israel is justified in its military action,
while fully 76% disapprove of Hezbollah’s attacks on Israel, according to
Gallup. A CNN poll found some 57% are sympathetic to Israel, while only 4%
are sympathetic to Hezbollah.
Actually, any other perception would be astonishing.
Israel is not an occupying power. It pulled out of Lebanon six years ago. The
Israeli withdrawal behind an internationally recognized border back in 2000
was supposed to be followed by the disarming of Hezbollah, as called for by
UN Security Council Resolution 1559.
That didn’t happen. On the contrary, Hezbollah,
supplied and financed by Iran and Syria, created a network of rockets and
weapons bunkers in southern Lebanon. Last month’s kidnapping and murder of
Israeli soldiers not engaged in hostilities, accompanied by the wave of
rockets fired into Israeli cities and towns, was a gross act of warfare and a
crime against humanity. The airborne weapons were packed with ball bearings -
not to destroy military assets but to maximize suffering by shredding human
flesh.”
SOURCE:
HEZBOLLAH'S HOMICIDAL HAND. WITH THE TERRORIST GROUP COMMITTED TO ISRAEL'S
DESTRUCTION, SELF-DEFENSE IS THE ONLY ANSWER, Daily News (New York),
August 7, 2006 Monday, SPORTS FINAL EDITION, EDITORIAL; Pg. 29, 458
words, BY MORTIMER B. ZUCKERMAN
[9] To read about
Franklin Delano’s policy toward the Jewish people in the middle of the
Holocaust, visit:
1939-1945 -- US policy toward the Jewish people during the World War; from “IS THE US AN ALLY OF ISRAEL: A Chronological look at the evidence”; Historical and Investigative Research; by Francisco Gil-White.
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hirally.htm#1939
[10] “‘Are you a
Jew?’ an extremely drunk Mel Gibson asked the Malibu traffic cop who had
pulled him over. Apparently without waiting for a response, the actor then
declared: ‘Fucking Jews. The Jews are responsible for all the wars in the
world.’”
SOURCE: Mel
Gibson isn’t the only conspiracy theorist, The Independent (London),
August 4, 2006 Friday, Final Edition, NEWS; Pg. 39, 1100 words, DOMINIC
LAWSON
[10a] "Was
Arab anti-Jewish racism in the first half of the 20th c. fundamentally
different from the European variety?"; from UNDERSTANDING THE
PALESTINIAN MOVEMENT; Historical and Investigative Research; 22 April 2006;
by Francisco Gil-White
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/pal_mov.htm
[10b] Simpson, C.
1988. Blowback: America's recruitment of Nazis and its effects on the Cold
War. New York: Weidenfeld & Nicholson.
[11] REAL CIVILIAN
CASUALTIES VS. THE FREEZER TRUCK HOAX; Historical and Investigative Research;
23 September 2002; by Francisco Gil-White & Jared Israel.
http://www.hirhome.com/yugo/freezer_app.htm
[12] At the height
of World War II, in 1943, Ruth Mitchell wrote a book entitled The Serbs Chose
War to document and celebrate the valiant fight of the Serbs against
German Nazism, and against Nazi allies within Yugoslavia. In her book she
reproduces in full a letter
"...written by a Jewish physician, a professor in the Department of Medicine in the University of Belgrade, to a friend in London on his escape from Yugoslavia in 1942. As the writer is a Jew, for the sake of relatives who remain in Yugoslavia his name cannot be used."
This letter tells a remarkable tale of Serbian moral
bravery. Here it is:
[Text Of The Letter Begins Here]
“In Yugoslavia there were 85,000 Jews,
including Jewish émigrés from Germany, Austria, Poland and Czechoslovakia.
Thanks to the Serbs, the Yugoslav Jews had succeeded in saving and rescuing many
of their compatriots from Germany and German-occupied countries. Service
rendered and assistance given to Jews by Yugoslav consular officials in
Austria and Czechoslovakia has specially to be recognized. Of the total
number of Jews in Yugoslavia about 7,500 were refugees.
“After the [Nazi invasion in 1941]...the Jews came under the rule of various
regimes, including Pavelich's 'Independent Croatian State'.
“The 'solution' of the Jewish question in the Independent Croatia devolved
upon the Croatian Ustashis. [This was the clerical-fascist regime set up in
Croatia with Nazi approval.] In Serbia, however, the Jewish problem was not
dealt with by the Serbs themselves. This the Germans reserved for themselves.
There are special reasons for this. When they occupied Serbia, the Germans
did not find any anti-Semitic feeling in the country. They could not persuade
either the local population or the local authorities to take any anti-Semitic
measures.
“The fact that Nedich [the Serbian quisling government, installed after the
Nazi invasion] twice demanded from the German commanding officer in Serbia
and the Banat that he and his government should be given the right to settle
the Jewish problem, against whom no drastic measures should and could be
taken in Serbia, shows the feeling of the Serbian people toward the Jews. The
following reasons were given by Nedich to the Germans for this demand. If the
Germans wanted the Serbs to calm down, it would be of first importance to
stop the terrible persecution of the Serbian Jews. The Serbian people could
not and would not accept such treatment 'of their compatriots of the Jewish
religion.' The Serbs consider Jews as their brothers, only of a different
religion. The answer which Nedich received from the Germans regarding this
demand was 'that the Serbs have not attained a culture to the degree
necessary to enable them to deal with the Jews. We ourselves shall settle the
Jewish question in Serbia.'
“With regard to anti-Semitism, Yugoslavia can be divided into two parts, i.e.,
districts where this feeling was latent, and Serbia, where, it can be said
without any exaggeration, anti-Semitic feeling has never had any root.
“During Yugoslavia's twenty-three years of existence, Serbia has always
professed the free democratic tradition existing in the former Kingdom of
Serbia. There in the nineteenth century, and later in the twentieth, the Jews
always had full civic rights and complete equality with their Serbian
compatriots. This equality was not only granted in various constitutions of
the Kingdom of Serbia and later of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia, but it was also
a true expression of the relationship between the Orthodox Serbs and the Jews
in their everyday contact. This friendly and amicable relationship also
existed in the economic, financial, and political life in Serbia. The small
group of Jews living in Serbia gave their contribution towards the cultural
and political life in Serbia's struggle for the formation of a state of South
Slavs. The Jews had in Serbia members of Parliament. In Serbia's struggle for
liberation, the Jews gave their contribution. Several were awarded the
Karadgeorge Star for bravery in the battlefield - equivalent to the British
V.C.
“About a year before Yugoslavia was attacked by Germany, by pressure from the
Reich and in their attempt to suit their policy to the dictators, the
Tsvetkovich-Machek Government passed the first anti-Semitic measure in
Yugoslavia. The Government was not unanimous on this point. Dr. Koroshets,
leader of the Slovenes, upheld the measure as Minister of Education. Serbian
cabinet ministers, however, including the Minister of War, refused to apply
the act. The application of it was confined to the Ministry of Education,
under the Slovene, Dr. Koroshets, and the Ministry of Trade and Industry,
under the Croat[ian], Dr. Andres.
“In all the schools and universities, numerous restrictions were applied by
circular, but in Serbia, Serb teachers and professors succeeded in avoiding
or sabotaging the regulations.
“In this regard Serbia completely differed from Croatia under Dr. Machek and
the district governor or Ban, Shubashich. In Croatia anti-Semitism was
inherited from Austria-Hungary. Anti-Semitic centers had always existed. Dr.
Shubashitch's Croatia had even prepared elaborate laws and regulations just
before the war broke out in Yugoslavia in 1941. A large part of the
industries in Jewish hands in Croatia was to be confiscated and nationalized.
Anti-Semitism was particularly stressed in Croatia by the right wing of Dr.
Machek's Croatian Peasant Party.
“This report could be divided into two parts - the first beginning with the
entry of German troops into Belgrade in April 1941 to the beginning of August
1941; the second from the middle of August 1941 until the closing down of the
office of the 'Jewish section' late in 1942. The section was closed because
there were no longer any Jews in occupied Serbia. During the first stage the
Jews were tortured, persecuted, maltreated, taken for forced labor.
Well-known Jews and Serbs were taken to German concentration camps. Women of
the intelligentsia class were forced to clean latrines in the German
barracks, to clean floors and sweep streets under the supervision of the S.S.
troops. They were made to clean the windows of high houses from the outside,
and several of them lost their lives through falling down. Jewish girls were
violated and taken to 'Militar-Medi'. Already during the first stage the Jews
were deprived of all their property and most of them were evicted from their
homes.
“In the second period male Jews were sent to concentration camps. But quite a
number of men and young Jews succeeded in escaping to the villages, where
they lived with Serbian peasant families. A number later joined the
guerrillas. A considerable number of youths from the Jewish Zionist
organization, which co-operated with the Serbian organizations for the
preparation of resistance, actively helped the guerrilla fighters. Many
collected hospital material for the guerrillas or posted anti-German posters
in Belgrade streets. The name of Almozmo, a schoolboy of ten, the son of a
well-known Belgrade dispensing chemist in Peter Street, should be mentioned.
He threw bombs at two armored German cars and a tank in Grobljanska Street in
Belgrade and blew them up. His elder brother, a medical student, is still
fighting in Bosnia, in spite of the order that the mayor and members of the
rural councils would be shot if such cases were discovered in their villages.
“Some forty of my relatives were shot in Belgrade by the Germans. I am,
however, very proud to say that today two small relatives of mine, one of
five and one of seven years of age, whose parents were shot by the Gestapo,
are being hidden by two Serbian mothers.
“No German measures in Belgrade were able to upset the friendly relations
between the Serbs and Jews. During the forced-labor period Serbs talked to
their Jewish friends in the streets even in front of the German soldiers and
police. During the period well over 300,000 Serbs were massacred by the Croat
Ustashi in Bosnia, Herzegovina, and Lika and some 60,000 shot by the Germans
in Serbia, during the period when Serbian students and peasants were hung in
the main square in Belgrade, the Serbs of the capital had sufficient courage
to protest publicly their indignation at the treatment of the Jews.
“When Jewish women were transported in lorries to the concentration camps,
Serb shopkeepers in the streets through which these processions passed closed
their shops and their houses, thus expressing not only their protest, but
also emphasizing the fact that the entire population of Serbia, yesterday and
today, does not and cannot participate in the extermination of their Jewish
neighbors.
“The example of the Serbian people with regard to the Jews is unique in
Europe, particularly in the southern part of the continent. In spite of
intensive German propaganda in writing and through the wireless, the Serbs
remained unaffected. When we consider what happened to the Jews in
neighboring countries, in the "Independent State of Croatia,"
Hungary, Rumania, and Bulgaria, the Serbian example shines out.
“Today there are no more Jews left in Serbia, except some children hidden by
the Serbs and those fighting along with the Serbs in the forests. I saved my
own life thanks to my Serbian friends. I was saved from certain death.
Serbian peasants and my other friends also saved from death my only son, who
was on several occasions sought by the Gestapo in Belgrade.
“It is my desire as a Jew and as a Serb that in free democratic countries
where Jews are still enjoying full freedom and equality they should show
gratitude to the Serbian people, pointing out their noble acts, their humane
feelings, and their high civic consciousness and culture....
“I cannot conclude this report without mentioning how the Serbian Orthodox
Church, the Patriarch Gavrilo, and his clergy tried to save Serbian Jews and
Gypsies. Up to the present day the Germans have massacred I70,000 Gypsies,
men, women, and children, in Serbia and the Banat. Serbian Orthodox priests and
the Serbian peasantry risked their lives not only to save ordinary Jews and
their children but also to save those Gypsies and their children. Today the
chief rabbi of Yugoslav Jews lives in America. He was saved from the Gestapo,
being smuggled out from Serbia from monastery to monastery by the Serbian
clergy. He was handed over by one Serbian church to another, by one Serbian
priest to another until he was passed on to Bulgarian territory. There, with
the assistance of the Orthodox Bulgarian clergy, some of whom were his
personal friends, he arrived at the Turkish frontier.”
[End Quote]
SOURCE: The Serbs Chose War, by Ruth
Mitchell, Garden City Publishers, New York, 1943, (pp.260-264)
[13] To read about
Izetbegovic’s Handzar Division, visit:
“Painting fascists as victims, and their victims as fascists: The mainstream media turned Bosnia upside down”; from WHAT REALLY HAPPENED IN BOSNIA?; Historical and Investigative Research; 19 August 2005; by Francisco Gil-White
http://www.hirhome.com/yugo/ihralija2.htm
The news service Reuters distributed
this phony photo in order to accuse the Israelis.
ISRAEL an HIR series █ Who attacked Israel? █ What is Hezbollah? █ What caused
this war? █ Understanding the US
position | 1 █ Understanding the US
position | 2 █ The Arab reaction, and what it means █ Who is killing Lebanese
civilians? | 1 █ Who is killing Lebanese
civilians? | 2 █ What is wrong with the
media? | 1 █ What is wrong with the media?
| 2 |
|
|
|
When a wire service such as Reuters lies, the
mainstream press lies across the board. This is enough to give one pause: the supposedly
free and independent press is in fact highly centralized. Is it also deliberately dishonest? And does it deliberately attack the Jews? |
|
|
|
|
Western civilization is Christian, and Christians
have defined themselves in opposition to Jews. Thus, Western history is one long series of
anti-Jewish massacres and expulsions caused by absurd accusations against
the Jewish people. These all stem, ultimately, from the Gospel
accusation that ‘the Jews’ supposedly murdered God. |
|
Notify me of new HIR pieces!
Hezbollah
Hizbollah Hizbu'llah Hizb'allah
What is
Hezbollah?
What is
Hizbollah?
What is
Hizbu'llah?
What is Hizb'allah?
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah3.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah4.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah4_2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah5.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah6.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah6_2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah7.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah7_2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hezbollah8.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/us_russia.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/us_russia.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/about_face.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/pal_mov.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/pal_mov2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/pal_mov3.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/pal_mov4.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/eichmann.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/subtle.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/leaders1.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/leaders2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/left_right2.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/mearsheimer_walt.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/seeds.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/mprot1.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/hirally.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/aipac.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/defense.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/ford.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/save.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/left_right1.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/israel/deir-yassin.htm
http://www.hirhome.com/yugo/ranta.htm